French regulator fines Amazon $35 million over its surveillance system of warehouse employees

France’s information privateness watchdog, the CNIL, has fined Amazon’s logistics subsidiary in France €32 million, or $35 million at immediately’s change price. The CNIL says that Amazon France Logistique has carried out a “surveillance system” that’s “overly intrusive.”

Specifically, the CNIL is specializing in the warehouse barcode scanner and Amazon’s information gathering practices associated to the linked system. When an order is processed, an Amazon picker grabs a product, scans it with the linked scanner and places it right into a crate in order that it may be shipped to the client. Equally, staff use the scanner to retailer new gadgets within the warehouse.

“Indicators monitoring the inactivity time of staff’ scanners have been put in place. The CNIL dominated that it was unlawful to arrange a system measuring work interruptions with such accuracy, probably requiring staff to justify each break or interruption,” the French regulator wrote.

Each the “idle time”, which signifies a interval of scanner downtime of ten minutes or extra, and the “latency beneath ten minutes”, which tracks scanner interruptions between one and ten minutes are deemed unlawful by the CNIL in the case of information processing. The CNIL is utilizing the GDPR because the authorized foundation of the case.

Amazon has additionally carried out a “stow machine gun” indicator to stop errors. It indicators an error for those who scan an merchandise lower than 1.25 seconds after scanning the earlier merchandise. It feels like a technique to stop double-scanning errors. However that’s a GDPR concern too, in response to the CNIL.

Once more, it’s value declaring that the CNIL is itemizing some information processing wrongdoings. This isn’t a labor case, it’s a knowledge processing case about illegitimate and extreme monitoring of the warehouse employees.

“The processing of those two indicators signifies that the worker is probably required to justify at any time that [they] are interrupting [their] scanner, even for a really brief time,” the CNIL wrote. “As carried out, the processing is taken into account to be excessively intrusive.”

In accordance with the French regulator, Amazon makes use of this efficiency information to evaluate the general efficiency of its warehouse employees on a weekly foundation.

“Extra typically, the CNIL thought of extreme to maintain all the info collected by the system, in addition to the ensuing statistical indicators, for all staff and non permanent employees, for a interval of 31 days,” the French regulator wrote.

Amazon’s reply

The corporate printed a prolonged assertion following the CNIL’s tremendous. “We strongly disagree with the CNIL’s conclusions, that are factually incorrect, and we’d attraction the choice,” Amazon wrote.

The corporate’s first argument is that Amazon isn’t the one firm within the logistics trade utilizing a linked warehouse administration system. Specifically, the corporate says that it helps in the case of load balancing between a number of warehouses and a number of other groups.

“If we face an order peak, our methods will assist us adapt the workload between groups in order that we are able to preserve processing orders in a secure and environment friendly method,” Amazon wrote.

And in additional particulars, Amazon says that the “stow machine gun” indicator has been created in order that employees can examine merchandise earlier than they’re saved to make it possible for they aren’t broken. The corporate will disable that indicator in its system.

As for the “idle time” metric, Amazon will lengthen the edge restrict. To any extent further, the corporate will set off this indicator after half-hour as a substitute of 10 minutes.

Leave a Comment